Nicholas R Mathenia, D.O.

174 Ratings27 Comments
Endeavor Health Medical Group
Hospital Affiliations:
Edward Hospital

View Website

This provider is an employee of one of the Edward-Elmhurst Health System entities.



Education & Credentials

Education: Midwestern University (Downers Grove), 2011

Internship: University of Illinois at Chicago College of Medicine, 2012

Residency: University of Illinois at Chicago College of Medicine, 2015

Fellowship: University of Chicago Medical Center (Illinois), 2016


To find out if this healthcare professional accepts your insurance plan, it is important to verify coverage with your health insurance company. Verify your coverage by either calling the number on your insurance card or confirming coverage through your insurance company’s website or mobile app.

Learn more about insurance coverage verification and Endeavor Health Medical Group’s accepted insurance plans.


Press Ganey Data Integrity Certified

Consumers who are considering a provider at Edward-Elmhurst Health now have an additional tool - online access to our patient satisfaction ratings and comments from verified patients. To obtain patient ratings and comments, we partner with Press Ganey, an independent patient satisfaction company that works with more than 26,000 health care organizations, including half of all U.S. hospitals, to improve the patient experience. Press Ganey uses the CAHPS® Hospital Survey and CAHPS Clinician and Group Practice Survey, to measure patients' health care experiences with their physician. 

Learn more about patient ratings and comments

Overall Patient Rating
4.9 out of 5
(174 Ratings, 27 Comments)
No Rating Given
Excellent doctor, listen very carefully.
No Rating Given
Dr Mathenia was excellent. He's a provider who listens to your concerns and explains his thoughts so well. Makes the patient and family feel comfortable to ask questions. Extremely knowledgeable and helpful. I highly appreciate the time he took during the exam.
No Rating Given
Dr. Mathenia and ... (RN) alway make every effort to accommodate my care needs and have been so wonderful in helping me deal with a tough diagnosis and the associated care needs. I truly appreciate their expertise and genuine care for my welfare.
No Rating Given
This was my first appointment with the neurologist and it could not have gone any better. He listened and asked if I had any more questions.
No Rating Given
Dr Methenia is excellent. Really listened to everything I was explaining to him, and it was a lot! He knew right away what my issue was most likely from. Discussed options, further care. Showed compassion and understanding.
No Rating Given
I have never felt rushed by Dr Mathenia or his staff even though I know they are very busy.
No Rating Given
I appreciate Dr. Mathenia and his willingness to include my concerns and preferences in tandem with his health care recommendations. He really listens to me and takes the time to not only give me an answer but explain the "why"s behind the answer. He's straightforward about what is known and unknown in the field about my medical conditions.
No Rating Given
Excellent service. Dr. Marhenia always listens and his explanations are easy to understand
No Rating Given
Excellent doctor. Hard to find great doctors like him these days
No Rating Given
Spends more time with me than I ever expect.