Nicholas R Mathenia, D.O.

47 Ratings14 Comments
Edward Neuroscience Institute
Hospital Affiliations:
Edward Hospital

This provider is an employee of one of the Edward-Elmhurst Health System entities.



Education & Credentials

Internship: University of Illinois at Chicago College of Medicine, 2012

Fellowship: University of Chicago Medical Center (Illinois), 2016

Insurance Accepted

Ambetter Secure Care HMO
Blue Choice MCNP PPO
Aetna Medicare POS
Aetna Medicare Advantage HMO
Aetna Medicare Advantage POS
AARP Medicare Advantage Complete (plan 1 & 2) (UHC) HMO
Blue Cross Community FHP-ICP
Blue Precision HMO
Coventry Workers Compensation Plan
MultiPlan PPO
UHC Medicare Advantage PPO
United HealthCare Core/Navigate EPO
United HealthCare Choice Plus PPO
United HealthCare Select POS
United HealthCare Select EPO
United HealthCare Core/Navigate HMO
Unicare PPO
United Healthcare Select HMO
Veterans Administration Community Care
SmartCare/Imagine Health PPO
Sunrise Advantage
United Healthcare Choice HMO
United HealthCare Core/Navigate POS
TriCare Standard/Reserve Select PPO
Three Rivers PPO
United Healthcare Choice EPO
United Healthcare Choice Plus POS
Humana Gold Plus HMO
Humana Choicecare PPO
Humana HMO
Humana Gold Plus Integrated MMAI
Great West Open Access
Great West POS
Great West PPO
HFN Workers Compensation Plan
Health Financial Network
Coventry (Personal Care)
Cigna C5 HMO
Cigna C5 POS
Aetna Medicare HMO
Coventry One PPO
Coventry First Health PPO
Coventry HMO
Coventry POS
Coventry PPO
Humana Gold Plus PPO
Illinos Medicaid
Longevity Health Plan of Illinois, Inc.
Medicare Part B
UHC Nexus ACO - Advocate PPO
UHC Nexus ACO - Advocate HMO
United HealthCare Choice Plus HMO
Blue Cross HMO Illinois (HMOI)
Blue Cross Medicare Advantage HMO
Blue Cross Medicare Advantage PPO
Blue Choice Options PPO
Blue Cross POS
Blue Cross PPO
Blue Choice Preferred
Aetna National Advantage Program
Beech Street PPO
Cigna C5 PPO
Aetna Medicare PPO
Aetna Medicare Advantage PPO
Ambetter Balanced Care HMO
AARP Medicare Advantage Complete (UHC) PPO
Blue Cross Blue Advantage HMO


Consumers who are considering a provider at Edward-Elmhurst Health now have an additional tool - online access to our patient satisfaction ratings and comments from verified patients. To obtain patient ratings and comments, we partner with Press Ganey, an independent patient satisfaction company that works with more than 26,000 health care organizations, including half of all U.S. hospitals, to improve the patient experience. Press Ganey uses the CAHPS® Hospital Survey and CAHPS Clinician and Group Practice Survey, to measure patients' health care experiences with their physician. 

Learn more about patient ratings and comments

Overall Patient Rating
4.5 out of 5
(47 Ratings, 14 Comments)
No Rating Given
Love Dr. Manthenia! He is a great doctor who listens, provides options for care and is generally concerned about your well being and works hard to help you meet your health goals. He was recommended to me by a Urgent Care Physician who had treated me from one of my severe migraines. best referral ever!
No Rating Given
thank you
No Rating Given
Felt doctor was quick to prescribe medication without really doing any type of evaluation. ( I still think I have a slightly pinched nerve in neck or something). He just said we had this same conversation a couple of years ago... he talked very fast and did not look at me -difficult to understand. I felt like he was talking at me instead of to me. not very personable and did not completely understand what he prescribed. Had to contact my primary doctor for explanation.
No Rating Given
Excellent Dr. and the staff are very attentive. Happy I made the switch.
No Rating Given
*Dr. Mathenia is great. I left a message and he returned my question promptly even after a nurse first talked to me.
No Rating Given
Visits with all my drs. are wonderful *Dr. [...], *Dr. [...] & *Dr. Mathenia.
No Rating Given
Must see DR. again.
No Rating Given
*Dr. Mathenia is excellent. He has been with me every step of the way since my occipital stoke - I trust him. He is thorough, caring & skilled - highly competent & knowledgeable.
No Rating Given
I have no idea how I could have been treated better.
No Rating Given
Dr. Mathenia is very personable and easy to understand. I trust his advise and direction