Nicholas R Mathenia, D.O.

68 Ratings20 Comments
Edward Neuroscience Institute
Hospital Affiliations:
Edward Hospital

This provider is an employee of one of the Edward-Elmhurst Health System entities.



Education & Credentials

Medical School: Midwestern University (Downers Grove), 2011

Internship: University of Illinois at Chicago College of Medicine, 2012

Residency: University of Illinois at Chicago College of Medicine, 2015

Fellowship: University of Chicago Medical Center (Illinois), 2016

Insurance Accepted

Aetna Medicare HMO
Aetna Medicare POS
Aetna Medicare PPO
Aetna Medicare Advantage HMO
Aetna Medicare Advantage POS
Aetna Medicare Advantage PPO
Ambetter Balanced Care HMO
Ambetter Secure Care HMO
AARP Medicare Advantage Complete (plan 1 & 2) (UHC) HMO
Blue Cross Community FHP-ICP
Blue Cross HMO Illinois (HMOI)
Blue Cross Medicare Advantage HMO
Blue Cross Medicare Advantage PPO
Blue Choice MCNP PPO
Blue Choice Options PPO
Blue Cross POS
Blue Cross PPO
Blue Choice Preferred
Blue Precision HMO
Aetna National Advantage Program
Beech Street PPO
Cigna C5 HMO
Cigna C5 POS
Cigna C5 PPO
Coventry (Personal Care)
Coventry One PPO
Coventry PPO
Coventry Workers Compensation Plan
Great West Open Access
Great West POS
Great West PPO
HFN Workers Compensation Plan
Health Financial Network
Humana Gold Plus HMO
Humana Gold Plus Integrated MMAI
AARP Medicare Advantage Complete (UHC) PPO
Blue Cross Blue Advantage HMO
Coventry First Health PPO
Coventry HMO
Coventry POS
Humana Choicecare PPO
Humana HMO
Medicare Part B
United Healthcare Choice EPO
United HealthCare Core/Navigate POS
UHC Medicare Advantage PPO
United HealthCare Core/Navigate EPO
UHC Nexus ACO - Advocate PPO
UHC Nexus ACO - Advocate HMO
United HealthCare Choice Plus HMO
United HealthCare Choice Plus PPO
United HealthCare Select POS
United HealthCare Select EPO
United HealthCare Core/Navigate HMO
Unicare PPO
United Healthcare Select HMO
Veterans Administration Community Care
Humana Gold Plus PPO
Illinos Medicaid
Longevity Health Plan of Illinois, Inc.
MultiPlan PPO
SmartCare/Imagine Health PPO
Sunrise Advantage
TriCare Standard/Reserve Select PPO
Three Rivers PPO
United Healthcare Choice HMO
United Healthcare Choice Plus POS


Press Ganey Data Integrity Certified

Consumers who are considering a provider at Edward-Elmhurst Health now have an additional tool - online access to our patient satisfaction ratings and comments from verified patients. To obtain patient ratings and comments, we partner with Press Ganey, an independent patient satisfaction company that works with more than 26,000 health care organizations, including half of all U.S. hospitals, to improve the patient experience. Press Ganey uses the CAHPS® Hospital Survey and CAHPS Clinician and Group Practice Survey, to measure patients' health care experiences with their physician. 

Learn more about patient ratings and comments

Overall Patient Rating
4.7 out of 5
(68 Ratings, 20 Comments)
No Rating Given
*Dr. Mathenia is very professional, he listened and explained everything. Nurses were great.
No Rating Given
All good experiences.
No Rating Given
Dr Mathenia was so knowledgeable and easy to talk to. I was able to and any questions without feeling rushed at all and had them all answered .
No Rating Given
My visit with Dr. Mathenia surpassed all expectations! He studied my previous record of tests and medications and surgeries; he knew exactly why I was there, and took time to answer my questions, as they came up. He is to be recognized for his thoroughness, and his dealing with patients. He is just amazing! Thank you Dr. Mathenia for taking time to care for me.
No Rating Given
everything was very good
No Rating Given
Dr Mathenia was great. Didn't act rushed and took time to answer all my questions and concerns. Also very thorough friendly and personable.
No Rating Given
All in office including Doc were very friendly.
No Rating Given
Dr. Mathenia tends to answer questions before I finish asking them. He doesn't listen as well as he talks.
No Rating Given
Dr. Mathenia is one of the best doctors I have ever met. He communicates very easily with patients, and is an excellent listener. By respecting patient input he encourages them to be an active part of their care.
No Rating Given
Dr. Mathenia was one of the best doctors I've ever seen. I went to him very worried about a health condition I hadn't been able to diagnose with many doctors before. He carefully listened to me with respect and asked a lot of questions and I didn't feel rushed through the appointment - he even apologized for taking up MY time which I've never experienced. He was incredibly thorough and empathetic. He ordered an MRI for me which a previous doctor was not responsive about getting approved by my insurance and it was denied (I spent 3 weeks trying to get it figured out), but Dr. Mathenia and his staff got it approved same day. When I got the MRI done, Dr. Mathenia called me personally HOURS after the MRI was done even though it was completely normal just because he knew I was worried about it and wanted to reassure me and make sure I didn't have any questions. I can't recommend Dr. Mathenia and staff enough.